Resurrection Sunday Update
As noted earlier, the translation of the Gospels that we’re working on will blend all four Gospel messages into a single account. In doing this, I’ve found some interesting evidence about what happened during the process of Jesus’ arrest, trials, and crucifixion and his resurrection. The Bible makes it obvious that some of our traditional ideas about what happened have to be wrong. Here are some of the things I learned:
- Our traditional idea is that Jesus was arrested in the early pre-dawn hours of Friday and was crucified that same day. That’s not what the Bible says. Mark records that Jesus was crucified at the third hour of the day (9:00 am), but John tells us that Pilate set up his judgment seat to pass Judgment on Jesus at the sixth hour of the day (noon). It’s obvious that the day Pilate passed judgment cannot be the same day as the day Jesus was crucified.
- In the same vein, our traditional view holds that Jesus was examined by Jewish authorities after dawn on Friday and then tried by Pilate, then by Herod, and then by Pilate again and was still on the cross by 9:00 that morning. This all happened in Jerusalem, an ancient town with narrow streets, while Passover crowds crammed the streets. There is no way that all of this could have happened between dawn and 9:00, even if we don’t include the mocking by Herod and his soldiers and the torture by Pilate’s soldiers and the fact that the Roman governor (Pilate) was trying to drag his feet.
- Matthew, Mark, and Luke all tell how Jesus and his disciples celebrated the Passover feast and how Jesus was arrested later that night. John tells how the Jewish leaders would not enter Pilate’s headquarters because that would make them ceremonially unclean and keep them from sharing in the feast. Moses’ law tells us that Passover was part of a 7-day feast (the Feast of Unleavened Bread), and that there were two feast days involved: the first day and the seventh day, each of which was a special Sabbath (not the normal Saturday Sabbath). John makes it clear that Jesus was crucified on the day before a special Sabbath (called a Preparation Day). The feast that Jesus and his disciples observed before he was arrested is clearly the first day, the official Passover feast. The feast John mentioned must be the seventh day, making several days between the arrest and the crucifixion.
- In AD 34, the Passover feast (always on the 15th day of the Jewish month Nisan) came on a Friday. If that was the day Jesus was arrested, then the seventh day was a Thursday and since Jesus was crucified on the day before that final feast he would have been crucified on a Wednesday and buried that evening just before sundown.
- The Bible tells us that the women came to the tomb on Sunday morning (the first day of the week about dawn), and that Jesus was not in the tomb when they arrived. The Bible does not tell us exactly when Jesus rose from the dead. If Jesus rose from the dead just after sunset on Saturday, according to the Jewish calendar that would be Sunday (the day changed at sunset), and Jesus would have been in the tomb three days and three nights just as he said he would be.
- Several women came to the tomb early Sunday morning, around dawn, and found the tomb empty. On seeing the empty tomb, Mary Magdalene left the group and ran outside, but the rest of the women then saw two of God’s agents sitting in the tomb. The agents told them that Jesus had risen from the dead and instructed them to tell Jesus’ disciples. They went to meet with Jesus’ disciples, and as they were going Jesus appeared to them. But when they got to the disciples, none of them would believe their story.
- Meanwhile, Peter, after his denial of Jesus, was not with the other disciples. (The agents of God had told the women to take the news to the disciples and Peter, indicating that Peter wasn’t with the rest.) Mary Magdalene, without having seen the agents or Jesus, was on her way to tell Peter that the body was no longer in the tomb. When she got to where Peter was staying, John was there, too. What she told them was not that Jesus had risen from the dead, but that the tomb was empty. That’s all she knew.
- Peter and John ran to the tomb to see for themselves what had happened. From what John says in his Gospel, he believed in the resurrection after seeing the linen wrappings lying in the empty tomb, even though the agents did not appear to him or Peter. Peter’s reaction is described more as confusion at that point. Then Peter and John left the tomb area, and Mary Magdalene arrived back at the tomb.
- Looking inside the tomb, this time Mary Magdalene saw the two agents of God, but she didn’t realize that they were anything but men working in the tomb area. She turned from the tomb and saw Jesus, but through her tears she didn’t recognize him until he spoke her name.
- At some point that day, and the Bible doesn’t tell us when, Jesus appeared to Peter after he left the tomb. We don’t know whether this happened while he was still with John or not. Jesus also appeared to two disciples who were not part of the inner circle of twelve, and then he finally appeared to the whole group (the inner circle group and probably some others) with the exception of Thomas. They were together in an upper room, probably the room where they had shared the Passover meal, in Jerusalem.
- A week later Jesus appeared to the inner circle group again, including Thomas. This time the Bible doesn’t tell us where they were, it only says that the doors were shut when Jesus suddenly appeared. By this time they may have been back in Galilee, since Jesus had given them instructions to go there.

Revitalizing Christianity Study Guide-3-Hole Loose-Leaf
Revitalizing Christianity – PDF eBook Download